We are open 6 days a week!

Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday 10 – 6


Friday 11-6 and Saturday 11-5

Open the last Sunday of the month for our Super Sale where everything is 25-50% OFF


We accept most anything and everything  for consignment other than clothing.

We do have a full list of what we do and do not accept.

We only ask  a couple of things:

  • Your items are clean as well as odor free and are ready to be sold
  • Your items have a minimum resale value of $3

YES! We do have a maximum of 2 boxes or 25 items per week. We ask that you bring in small items in level stackable boxes or totes and that clothing come in on hangers.

No appointment is necessary, however we only accept items Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. With over 900 consignors we do not have the ability to go through your items upon arrival. We make sure you have labeled your boxes  and we store them until it is your turn. This usually takes between 3-5 days. We ask that you call or stop by after that time to pick up any items we may not accept.

Leave the pricing up to us! We do the research and figure out the fair resale market value for your items and go from there. If you have a price that you need for an item please let us know so that we can take that into consideration when pricing your items.

We split the sale price of the item 50/50. If you bring in hand-made items we only take a 30%cut.

Your items are consigned for a total of 90 days. The price breakdown is as follows: An item goes in at full price, after 30 days it goes down 25%. If your item does not sell within that time frame it will go down to 50% for an additional 30 days.

Yes we can! We now offer an instant credit program for your items. If you have something that you are looking to get rid of but don’t want to go through the entire consignment process you can get an instant credit as soon as you bring in your items.

We now offer pickup and delivery.

We charge $10 for the first 10 miles and .25 cents per mile for additional miles.

Have items you would like to consign or sell but can’t get them to us? Give us a call!

Find something at the shop you can’t get home? We can deliver!


We currently do not have it set up to purchase items online; however, if you see an item on-line that you would like to purchase you may put it on hold. Almost every item we have available is unique so once it is on hold we will call you to let you know if it is still available. If still available you will need to pick up the item(s) within 72 hours. *Placing an item on hold IS a commitment to purchase.

For any purchase over $50 we do offer layaway with just 20% down and the balance due within 30 days.

If desired, you can reclaim unsold items within seven days before the consignment expiration date. We do NOT notify you prior to the expiration date. Expired items become property of Finders Keepers of Erie after the 90 day expiration date.